Physician Who is incessantly dangerous tv. In some methods, it’s a part of the attraction: dodgy manufacturing values redeemed by impressed storytelling or character work, or clunkily camp B-movie sci-fi elevated by glimmers of spectacle, the perpetual promise of huge concepts craving to flee one holdback or one other. So hardly ever do these myriad failings mix, so hardly ever do these large concepts fail to emerge, to ship a very wretched piece of tv. That scrappy attraction regardless of all of it is considered one of a number of causes that, identical to its protagonist, the collection has managed to cheat dying for over 60 years.
Sadly, all these issues mixed this previous weekend in “The Actuality Warfare.” They usually made for a state so dire that perhaps Physician Who shouldn’t get out of this one, at the very least for a very good lengthy whereas.
You’ll be able to’t actually describe the plot of “Actuality Warfare,” in a lot that it’s much less a coherent narrative and extra of a group of scenes that hardly maintain issues collectively—some altogether good, some altogether irritating—earlier than they’re pressured to break down with nonetheless a very good third of its run time to go, to present solution to a sudden lengthy goodbye to Ncuti Gatwa’s fifteenth Physician—one sudden surprise amongst a number of that feels much less prefer it was the plan for this story, and extra like bracing for the present’s still-uncertain future. Characters, typically actually, vanish out and in of proceedings as they’re wanted (some are shoved right into a field, truly actually, which we’ll get to). Plot threads constructed up throughout the season both get left hanging, minimize off abruptly, or in some instances, simply undone for the sake of a totally completely different change in path.
A multitude from a manufacturing standpoint, once more, could be redeemed partly if “Actuality Warfare” had something incisive to say concerning the mishmash of characters it begins flinging about its myriad plot threads, however alas, it’s a story as incoherent from a thematic and narrative standpoint as it’s logistically. From the second the Physician is saved from final week’s cliffhanger—falling into the underverse, alongside the remainder of actuality—by the arrival of Anita from the 2024 Christmas special (who has fallen in love and turn out to be pregnant, some extent that may turn out to be necessary later, however in any other case largely exists to carry doorways open, a method for the Time Resort she now works for to let the prime actuality start to flood again into existence), “Actuality Warfare” is on a scramble. First, to snap our numerous heroes and UNIT out of Conrad’s Obligatory Heterosexuality Actuality from last week (that may also turn out to be necessary later), after which to have them thrust into the trail of the vengeful Rani as she explains why she is attempting to impress the principles of existence into granting her entry to Omega’s imprisonment beneath actuality itself.
That motive is, reasonably succinct, and in a second the place “Actuality Warfare” slowing down to really have its characters talk about one thing collectively works. Desperately searching for a solution to restore her folks with Omega’s physique to avoid wasting the Time Lord race from the aftermath of genetic sterilization (though it’s unclear just which calamity the Time Lords and Gallifrey confronted the Rani is referring to right here), it lets Archie Panjabi’s Rani turn out to be, in distinction to final week’s Grasp-like villainess cackling about needs and prophecy, that chilly, sinister lady of science she was in classic Who, ruthless and blinded at any price of discovering the reply wrought of her experiments. A Rani who makes a callous comment about humanity as impure cattle beneath her—as a result of Poppy, the Physician and Belinda’s Want-World youngster is a mixture of human and Time Lord DNA—after which jokes that she’s misplaced the room for making a discriminatory comment is pure Rani, and much away from the primarily new character with an old name we’d been delivered final week.
It’s a disgrace then, that as spectacle forces all of the speaking to cease and the motion to start, that “Actuality Warfare” the simply as shortly discards this Rani, and its bizarre take on Omega, and brings the episode’s entire set of stakes to a juddering crash of a conclusion. As quickly because the Rani departs, the Physician shoves Belinda and Poppy right into a literal field—a tiny room inbuilt a handful of hours by Susan Triad, of all folks, to guard anybody inside from the results of the Want World actuality being erased solely—and duties Ruby to go confront Conrad, whereas he chases after the Rani… solely to look at Omega emerge from his jail as a large, baby-ish skeleton, eat her, after which be blasted again into his jail by the Physician taking pictures him with the charged up Vindicator.
All this—the second the collection has been constructing in direction of all season, the return of villains from its previous for the primary time in many years—is resolved in a handful of minutes in the midst of the episode. The Mrs. Flood incarnation makes a glib Two Ronnies joke and promptly vanishes, however Omega and the brand new Rani are handled all of the dramatic weight of a uninteresting thud. The day is just not fairly but saved although, as in the meantime, Ruby has to confront the person who first harassed and stalked her, after which re-wrote the whole lot of earth right into a dystopian actuality the place strict conventional roles of gender and sexuality rule the day (trans folks actually can’t exist in Conrad’s world, we study this week, when Yasmin Finney’s Rose Noble pops again into existence early within the episode, when you had been excited so as to add one other bigotry to Conrad’s lengthy record!) and minorities just like the disabled are an invisible second class.
Her decision to this confrontation with arguably considered one of Physician Who‘s most compellingly terrible villains in years? To inform him he should be terrible as a result of he had a nasty childhood, after which use the want child the Rani picked as much as facilitate this entire wretched factor to want him a contented life, freed from any of the results of his heinous actions from both these episodes or earlier in “Lucky Day”. Physician Who loves itself a sympathetic villain, positive, however Conrad by no means argued for, or justified, his retrograde attitudes: he fortunately was simply an terrible individual, and as a substitute of going through any form of reckoning and even acknowledging that, considered one of his largest victims as a substitute will get to want him to freedom. Oh, and Ruby’s adoptive mom will get a brand new child to lift too, giving Ruby the prolonged household she’d been searching for all through her time on the present.
So after getting rid of all three (technically 4, when you depend the Ranis) of its villains with a very good 20 minutes to go, what different ignominy can “Actuality Warfare” supply? The whole and whole re-writing—and primarily assassination of—Belinda Chandra as an fascinating character.
As Conrad’s want world actuality begins to buckle, it initially looks as if shoving Belinda and Poppy in a field has labored, however simply as quickly as she, the Physician, and Ruby start to have fun, Poppy vanishes from actuality and their recollections… save for Ruby’s, whose prior expertise with altered realities offers her some capability to retain some recollection. After being gaslit for a couple of minutes by the Physician, Belinda, and her UNIT colleagues, Ruby’s pleas ultimately break via, and Belinda—who had briefly escaped the tradwife model of herself that Conrad had wished her into in his actuality—all of the sudden flips again into her singular driving want being safeguarding Poppy. It’s her want to see the kid once more that sees the Physician related make a sudden pivot, deciding to present his present incarnation’s life to gas the TARDIS with an amazing shunt of regenerative vitality, permitting it to twist actuality simply sufficient to avoid wasting the life of a kid that in any other case wouldn’t exist.
On the floor, this is able to be an extremely compelling method for the Physician to exit. The Ninth Physician died to avoid wasting Rose from the facility she absorbed to turn out to be the Unhealthy Wolf, the Tenth gave his personal to avoid wasting Wilfred Mott, even all the way in which again into the basic period, you possibly can see the Fifth Physician’s relentless, deadly quest to avoid wasting Peri, a lady he’d simply met, in “The Caves of Androzani”—echoed right here. However “Actuality Warfare” by no means truly builds as much as this determination in a dramatically natural method. The Physician isn’t fatally wounded within the strategy of stopping the Rani and Omega or something; a part of the preliminary tragedy is that he seemingly forgot Poppy’s existence together with the remainder of the world when Conrad’s want dissipated. He simply decides that now he has to die, to do that one factor, even when it doubtlessly means sundering all of time and house, as he’s warned by none aside from the 13th Doctor, who will get to make a short, reassuring look as actuality begins to crack, first to attempt to cease her future self however then to finally help him, realizing the noble intent behind his actions. It’s once more, one other uncommon second the place in isolation “Actuality Warfare” shines, however solely in that isolation, faraway from any of the incoherence that result in the second within the first place.
The Physician’s plan works, nevertheless, and we return to earth with a dying Time Lord reuniting with a fortunately mothering Belinda. Actuality has shifted, we’re informed by way of retroactive flashbacks to factors all through the season, to ascertain that Poppy was at all times Belinda’s daughter, and her motive for getting residence wasn’t as a result of she had her work and life to get again to. It was as soon as a life that the Physician and his world had whisked her away from with little in the way in which of consent—however now, that life is Poppy herself. Retroactively having actuality itself set up a complete character arc that beforehand dig not exist all through the season would possibly carry a stage of existential horror to it, akin to Belinda’s preliminary difficult of the Physician’s personal invasive attitudes on the climax of “The Robot Revolution”. However that model of Belinda Chandra—a robust, independently minded individual, one who pressured the Physician to earn her belief by realizing the place her boundaries had been—is discarded with a handwave. She’s changed by a Belinda whose sole defining trait is motherhood to Poppy, a want she by no means even expressed earlier than (and was arguably in opposition to, in some methods, once we met her along with her first poisonous boyfriend Alan!).
That familial want isn’t inherently a nasty trait to present a personality, but it surely’s one which was by no means as soon as truly indicated as a part of Belinda’s story throughout this season. If something, it feels extra true of Ruby, after her seek for her start mom and her personal emotions about being adopted. This complete plotline is thrust upon Belinda in a alternative she doesn’t actively make—both when Conrad needs Poppy into existence within the first place, or when the Physician decides to interrupt actuality for her—and the nail is hammered into the coffin once we watch her not say a single phrase because the Physician, with out even asking, scans Poppy together with his sonic screwdriver to substantiate that she has been restored to actuality as fully human, reasonably than with any Time Lord DNA.
The very factor Belinda first challenged the Physician on again within the first episode of the season now goes by unquestioned! For a season that began so strongly with this imaginative and prescient of Belinda, solely to finish it with a whole absence of her starting characterization, taking an precise characterization of motherhood and watering all the way down to a singular, flat trait is past disappointing. Final week, the enforcement of a standard, matronly position on Belinda by Conrad’s usurpation of actuality was a horrifying factor, a breach of consent and signal to the viewers of his dystopia being fallacious and aberrant. Now the Physician primarily re-enacts that very same actuality again onto her, and it’s Belinda’s completely satisfied ending.
Whereas that’s the place we go away Belinda, seemingly for good, “Actuality Warfare” has one final confounding twist to present, because the fifteenth Physician prepares to say goodbye. Once more, this can be a fleeting second that in isolation works: it’s a good looking goodbye to a Physician that embodied a lot pleasure and lightness, to need to exit sharing his explosive vitality one final time with a universe he cherished, regenerating as he flings the doorways of the TARDIS out to see the good breadth of the cosmos past him. Besides, that regeneration ends with a well-recognized face: Ncuti Gatwa’s Physician offers method in a flash of sunshine to Billie Piper, who, after all, is known for having performed Rose Tyler (and the Unhealthy Wolf, and the Second) throughout Russell T Davies’ preliminary time period as showrunner. Having a landmark Physician by way of illustration regenerate into a well-recognized face from that 2005-2009 period of the present could be a shock, albeit a barely questionable one if we hadn’t already done this two years in the past. Gatwa’s time because the Physician, already cruelly brief, is now bookended by two “bizarre” regenerations that overshadow each his arrival (particularly in a lot as that, in bi-generation, David Tennant’s 14th Physician obtained to stay round) and his exit with a play to nostalgia. A play that we don’t know precisely the way it’s going to play out any time quickly, provided that Physician Who‘s newest finish has but to come back with news of its renewal. That is the final Physician Who we’ll get to see for at the very least a number of years, and it’s a second the place the present’s future ought to really feel bursting with potential. As a substitute, it’s closed doorways and rehashed low-cost methods.
If “The Interstellar Tune Contest” represented a imaginative and prescient of Physician Who at its most cowardly from a politically minded standpoint—so unwilling to be seen as saying something it supplied singsong within the face of genocide, whereas torturing its victims—then “Want World” and “Actuality Warfare” collectively as an entire signify a imaginative and prescient of the present at its most creatively cowardly. A companion that challenges the Doctor? Out the window for a one-note character to be discarded and outlined by a singular motherly trait. The return of basic villains with one thing to say about their place within the fashionable period? Smoothed over, minimize brief, discarded as emptily as they’re launched. A vibrant future of recent promise? Solely previous faces, previous concepts, reheated and re-delivered on the expense of losing a generational expertise.
Whoever Billie Piper’s mysterious determine portends to be because the present clumsily teases that there could also be greater than meets the attention to this regeneration, at any time when we get to search out out, ought to the BBC’s cope with Disney fall through or carry on, the one factor that’s clear coming of out “The Actuality Warfare” is that the present model of Physician Who can’t keep it up like this. Physician Who has no future with out constructing on its previous, to make sure, however because it stands, its inventive guideline within the right here and now has little interest in constructing on it: solely returning to it in more and more arcane and shallow methods, pointing fingers and jangling keys over any significant engagement that may set the stage for future concepts and vitality.
Maybe, for now, this needs to be the top. The second has actually been ready for, in delivering an period of the present at its absolute nadir.
Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and every thing it’s good to find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.
