The top of the most recent season of Physician Who could be controversial for many causes past its shocking cliffhanger ending—from its confounding narrative choices to its complete character re-writing of its newest companion—however maybe what has made it attain one other degree of ire is that, for the foreseeable future, this is perhaps it. Proper now, the continuation of Physician Who on TV is in about as uncertain a spot as it may be for the primary time in 20 years. In fact, the present has contemplated catastrophe throughout these twenty years, however we principally realized of these moments properly after the very fact: on the general public entrance, Physician Who persevered into the establishment it has develop into, despite all of it.
However Physician Who ends its newest run of episodes with out that public acknowledgement of its personal inevitability. For all of the discuss of scripts and eventual, doable continuity, proper now there’s at present no additional Physician Who confirmed past a five-episode spinoff collection, War Between the Land and the Sea. The present won’t air this vacation season; for the primary time because it returned, a 3rd season of this Disney-BBC partnership period has not been commissioned. Physician Who, on-screen at the very least, is at present standing on the sting of a proverbial cliff.
That doesn’t imply that Physician Who is essentially lifeless. Physician Who will all the time dwell on in some type or one other: it did again in 1989 when it was first cancelled, thriving in books, audio dramas, the transient spike of the 1996 TV film, all earlier than it got here roaring again to life once more in 2005. It additionally doesn’t imply that there aren’t choices for the collection, both, even on this second of uncertainty. Let’s discover a couple of of them.
Choice 1: Physician Who Continues As-Is
Of all of the choices on the desk proper now, this looks like the least possible. Not due to the angle of Physician Who‘s shaky repute popping out if its finale, and its wild stunt-casting Hail Mary to shut out Ncuti Gatwa’s time on the present (it’s at present unclear whether or not or not Billie Piper goes to be a full-fledged sixteenth incarnation of the Physician; very similar to the present’s present standing, particulars about which might be nonetheless up the air), however as a result of at this level it’s just about logistically inconceivable for the collection to make a return any time quickly until it enters manufacturing instantly.
Per week out from the finale and with no official assertion on the renewal of the BBC’s licensing partnership with Disney—with the latter already having made it clear that there was going to be a overview of Physician Who‘s viewership throughout the most recent season earlier than any determination concerning the deal—it appears unlikely that we’re going to listen to something quickly, whether or not Disney backs out or carries on financially supporting the collection. A Christmas particular for 2025 is already out of the image at this level; one was not included within the unique settlement. And even when we obtained information of a deal imminently, the likeliness of a brand new season of Physician Who being broadcast earlier than 2027 narrows to the purpose of impossibility with every passing day.
The query is, nonetheless, even when Physician Who was renewed within the rapid future, ought to it proceed as-is? It’s develop into clear—and it’s additionally clearly a part of the explanation why an official renewal didn’t include the conclusion of the most recent season—that Physician Who has struggled in the past few years to reclaim a wider viewers once more. Placing apart right-wing tradition battle accusations of overt “wokeness” within the collection (it has arguably been an period the place Physician Who‘s long-standing progressive themes have by no means been so purely surface-level), a mixture of a streaming-first strategy that has shaken up broadcast instances in Physician Who‘s house nation and plotlines which might be failing to energise both diehard followers or new audiences has led to the collection being on a scores decline. In a interval that was meant to be a brand new onboarding level for curious world audiences—a brand new Physician, a brand new companion, a distancing for latest and additional flung continuity threads—the collection has as an alternative wrapped itself in rising insularity, constructing its dramatic climaxes on arcane connections to Who‘s previous and season arcs that construct in the direction of the return of more and more obscure outdated villains, whereas additionally paradoxically failing to capitalize on these returning characters.
Even when Physician Who was greenlit for extra seasons, whether or not or not its present self is working would stay unsure.
Choice 2: Physician Who Takes a Break
So perhaps the present takes a break that’s longer than the logistically enforced couple of years it might take to proceed on because it has been. Whether or not that’s three years somewhat than two, whether or not it’s three or 4 and even 5, it might give the present the prospect to have a artistic reset behind the scenes and return with a renewed plan for its future and a renewed power with a totally new Physician and companion. That doesn’t essentially imply that a lot adjustments behind the scenes, nevertheless it may relying on the size of the break.
We now have, at the very least, the upcoming Battle Between the Land and the Sea to behave as one thing already made that might be broadcast within the place of a conventional season. However given the present uncertainty as to what Billie Piper’s position on this transitional interval might be—whether or not she’s the Physician in any respect, whether or not she’s a regeneration just like David Tennant’s 14th and received’t stick round lengthy, or whether or not she is certainly a fully-fledged incarnation that may keep because the face of the collection for a number of seasons—maybe we may even see one thing akin to what occurred with Physician Who in 2009. Then, because the collection ready to transition between the exit of each its most important star in David Tennant and its artistic management in showrunner Russell T Davies, Who went on a quasi-break for the yr, as an alternative broadcasting 4 one-off particular episodes all through 2009, whereas a brand new artistic staff below Steven Moffat started engaged on getting the subsequent period of the present prepared for broadcast in 2010.
Possibly after Battle Between the Land and the Sea we’ll see an identical “specials” period for Piper, earlier than a return to common seasons with a brand new incarnation of the Physician. Regardless, it might give time for Physician Who‘s artistic staff to try the final couple of years of the present, see what’s working and what isn’t, and lay out a brand new plan for what the collection may finally appear like upon its return.
Choice 3: Physician Who Dies (However Not Actually)
Or perhaps, that is it. In not having a deal renewed in any respect, whether or not with Disney’s assist or with out it, Physician Who is successfully cancelled because it was again in 1989. On display Who goes out with Piper’s smiling face chopping to credit, a extra open-ended however related conclusion akin to the Seventh Physician and Ace strolling off into adventures unseen on the finish of “Survival.”
In fact, which means that we all know that even when Physician Who on TV is lifeless, it actually isn’t lifeless in any respect. Simply as was the case almost 40 years in the past, the present’s first wandering into “The Wilderness Years,” as they got here to be recognized in Physician Who fandom, didn’t actually imply that Who ceased to exist. Virgin’s New Adventures novels carried on the tales of the Physician and Ace, and but additional past, offering a treasure trove of tales pushing the world of Physician Who past the imaginings of its televised self. The Large End audio drama collection started in 1999 and continues to today, concurrently giving Paul McGann’s Eighth Physician from the TV film a complete lifetime of adventures whereas additionally revisiting Medical doctors previous, enriching their very own histories with extra tales and spinoffs.
In suits and begins, we did nonetheless get glimpses of recent Physician Who media, from the tacky reunions of Dimensions in Time, to the aforementioned tried revival with the 1996 film, after which issues like the net internet animation Scream of the Shalka in 2003. However whereas Physician Who wasn’t usually on TV any extra, it was removed from dormant. We’ve already seen the collection survive one such interval, solely to come back again and alter the face of style tv once more. Who’s to say it couldn’t do the identical once more? In spite of everything, dishonest loss of life is a part of the important thing to Physician Who‘s longevity!
Need extra io9 information? Take a look at when to count on the most recent Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and all the things you must find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.
